Paddlefish 2025 Dinner Menu and Prices
Last Updated: December 2024
Reader Reviews:
Discounts Available:
Annual Passholder 10%
Disney Vacation Club 10%
Disney Dining Plan:
Signature Dining (2 table service meals) (2025)

Notes
Entree finishing touches include:Oscar $12
Blue Cheese $6
Bearnaise $4
Add-ons for boils:
Three jumbo shrimp $15
Dozen clams $9
1/2 lb of Mussels $9
Portuguese Chourico $8
Add chicken to your salad $9, shrimp to your salad $10 or salmon to your salad for $12.
Sides are sized to share.
Dessert
New York-Style Cheesecake farm-fresh strawberry compote $12
Key Lime Pie With graham cracker crust and torched meringue $12
Chocolate Mousse Cake berries with whipped cream $12
Chocolate Cookie Sundae chocolate cookies with vanilla ice cream $12.00
2023 MAY- Cocktail of the Month! Amy's Marvelous Mule Mezcal shaken with Elderflower Liquor, Lime Juice, Simple Syrup, Ginger Beer, & Cucumbers
Appetizers/Starters
Calamari shishito pepper, peppadew piri piri sauce $19
Fried Green Tomatoes elote, queso fresco, remoulade $15
Ahi Poke sweet black soy, avocado, radish, cucumber pickle, tortilla chips $18
Shrimp Cocktail jumbo shrimp, classic cocktail sauce $20
Crab Ceviche blue crab, avocado, bell pepper, jalapeno, cilantro, lime, tortillas $19
Crab Guacamole Blue Crab, Onion, Tomato, Jalapeño, Cilantro, Lime, Avocado and Tajin Tortilla Chips (Serves 4) $38
Crab Cake Crispy chourico, shishitos, sweet chili aioli $16
Oysters on the Half Shell Cocktail & Mignonette sauces 1/2 dozen or dozen $Market Price
Sausage and Peppers Crispy chourico, shishitos, sweet chili aioli $17.00
Grilled Octopus White beans, andouille, paprika oil $21
Soup/Salad
Green Salad Baby greens, radish, romaine, radicchio, cucumber, grape tomato, crispy wonton, red onion, roasted shallot vinaigrette; full $14, side $9
Caesar Salad Romaine hearts, garlic herb croutons, shaved asiago; full $14, side $9
Wedge Salad iceberg, tomatoes, red onions, bacon, blue cheese dressing; full $15, half $14
Caprese Salad Heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, olive oil, basil $13
Watercress Salad Apple, blue cheese, radish, hazelnut, sherry vinaigrette $12
Prix Fixe Menu
Animated Evening – Cirque du Soleil Dining Package Prix Fixe Menu Beverage - Choose One
Glass of Fire Road Sauvignon Blanc
Appetizer - Choose One
Tuna Poke
Entrée - Choose One
Catch of the Day • Peel & Eat Key West Shrimp
Dessert - Choose One
Key Lime Pie $65 per person
Glass of Fire Road Sauvignon Blanc
Appetizer - Choose One
Tuna Poke
Entrée - Choose One
Catch of the Day • Peel & Eat Key West Shrimp
Dessert - Choose One
Key Lime Pie $65 per person
Entrees
Alaska King Crab DDP $22 additional; served with Plant City Farmer's Market corn on the cob, new potatoes $75
Scallops Cauliflower puree, haricots verts, honey saffron vinaigrette $39
Filet Mignon 8 ounce, mashed potatoes, asparagus, bearnaise $54
Swordfish mussels, coconut milk, crab broth, tomato, peppers, ginger $30
Shrimp & Grits cheddar grits, spicy black pepper butter sauce $33
Cioppino shrimp, littleneck clams, mussels, octopus, seasonal fish, crab, tomato broth $39
Prime Strip 12 ounce, mushroom and onion demi glace $49
Pork Osso Bucco Cider braised, cheddar grits $28
Pork Chop Herb roasted potatoes, marinated peppers, chimichurri $31
Catch of the Day Couscous, garden vegetables, tropical fruit salsa $40
Shrimp Pasta Linguine, Florida Rock shrimp, asparagus, tomato, crab broth $28
Crispy Shrimp flash-fried, cocktail sauce, skin-on fries $24
Vegetarian Pasta Linguine, garlic, olive oil, market vegetables | Make it a surf & turf, $30 to add lobster tail $22
Chicken Breast Carolina Mop Sauce, Edamame-smoked Bacon Succotash $24
Mahi Caponata, salsa verde, herb roasted potatoes $32
Rib-Eye 16 ounce, herb roasted potatoes, house-made steak sauce $52
Catfish Cornmeal Crust, Edamame-smoked Bacon Succotash, Creole Mustard $27
Linguine & Clams Cedar Key Littlenecks, White Wine, Garlic, Lemon, Parsley $26
Whole Maine Lobster Sweet Corn on the Cob, Red Potatoes, and Cornbread $70
Stuffed Cod Shrimp and Scallop Corn Bread Stuffing, Asparagus, Red Potato, Mustard Cream Sauce $39
Snow Crab Sweet Corn on the Cob, Red Potatoes, and Cornbread $60.00
1 Pound P.E.I. Mussels served with Sweet Corn on the Cob, Red Potatoes, and Cornbread $20.00
Cedar Key Littleneck Clams served with Sweet Corn on the Cob, Red Potatoes, and Cornbread $24.00
Etouffee Crawfish, shrimp, basmati rice $30
Linguine & Clams Linguine, Florida Littleneck clams, garlic, anchovy, miso, white wine $32.00
Flounder Nuoc cham, bok choy, exotic mushroom $37.00
Sandwiches
Caprese Sandwich Fresh Mozzarella, Beefsteak Tomato, Basil Aïoli, Ciabatta $15
Side Dishes
Crispy Brussels Sprouts $10
Asparagus $10
Edamame Bacon Succotash $12
Maque Choux $10
Mac N' Cheese $15
Blistered Green Beans $9
Skin-on Fries $7
Red Bliss Potatoes $7
Lobster Tail $19
King Crab side portion $35
Shrimp side portion $10
Late Night Dining
Crab Fries hand cut potatoes, lump blue crab, Louie dressing $13
Gazpacho Oyster Shooters 3 market fresh oysters, tomato, bell pepper, cucumber $12
Salmon Tartare cucumber, red onion, dill, creme fraiche, caviar, crostini $13
Market Fresh Oysters champagne-cucumber mignonette, cocktail sauce $Market Price
Steak Tartare capers, anchovy, Dijon, quail egg, crostini $16
Seafood Charcuterie pastrami salmon, tuna bacon, shrimp escabeche $23
Caviar Mote Marine black sturgeon, blini, creme fraiche, quail egg, onion $Market Price
Specialty Beverages (non-alcoholic)
Cucumber Sipper Cucumber, simple syrup, fresh lime juice, lemonade | Make it a cocktail by adding your favorite liquor 7 $11.00
Specialty Cocktails
Lilly Spritz Mas Fi, Cocchi Rosa, seltzer $14.00
The Privateer Santa Teresa Anejo Rum, passion fruit, pineapple juice, fresh lemon $16.00
Southern Sangria James Pepper Bourbon, Peach Liqueur, Tempranillo, Seasonal Fruit $18
Not Everyone's Margarita Amaras Mezcal, Cuervo Traditional Plata tequila, Jalapeño, Creme de Mure, house sour, black salt $17.00
Captain Handsome Cathead vodka, fresh raspberries, framboise, thyme house sour $18
Gold Rush
West Cork Irish Whiskey, Fever Tree Ginger Beer, fresh lime
$20.00The Privateer Hayman's London Dry, Comoz Vermouth Blanc, Garden Party Cucumber $15.00
Lili's Steamboat Breeze Broadbent Rose, Cathead Honeysuckle, Elderflower, Fresh Lemon $17
Kendra's Mez'Merizer Vida mezcal, Grand Marnier, agave nectar, lime juice, orange juice $14
Hawaiian Shipmate
Islamorada Hibiscus Gin, Pineapple Juice, Orgeat, Lemon Juice $17.00
Islamorada Hibiscus Gin, Pineapple Juice, Orgeat, Lemon Juice $17.00
Steven's Old Fashioned G & W Bourbon, Angostura bitters, splash black cherry juice | Sub Paddlefish Knob Creek single barrel 7 $18
Twisted Spritz Aperol, Cathead Bitter Orange Vodka, Mas Fi Cava, fresh orange and strawberry, Sprite $18
Mayan Empress Santa Teresa Anejo Rum, peach liqueur, pineapple juice, fresh lemon $17.00
Kentucky Mule Paddlefish Knob Creek single barrel bourbon, Lime juice, Ginger Beer $20.00
Classic Margarita Cuervo Traditional Plata Tequila, Agave Nectar, Fresh Lime Juice, Black Salt | Sub Paddlefish Dobel Diamante Private Select 7 $16
Key Lime Spritz 50 States vodka, JF Hayden’s Key Lime, amaretto, lime juice, sprite $18
Florida Mule 50 States vodka, lime juice, ginger beer $18
Kayla's Rock & Roll Hurricane Hurricane Rum, Grand Marnier, Orgeat, lime juice, ginger beer $18
Beer
Draft $9.00
American Craft $9.00
Imported $8.00
Domestic includes gluten-free and non-alcoholic $7.00
Wine
Wines reds, whites, dessert $10-25
House-made Red/White Sangria Assorted premium fruity liquors, juices, white or red wine, seltzer, seasonal fruit | Carafe 50 ; glass $15
Spirits
Brandy & Cognac $18 - $69
Scotch $18 - $90
Bourbon $15 - $39
Cordials $12 - $18
Old Forester Flight 1870 Original Batch, 1897 Bottled in Bond, 1910 Old Fine Whisky | Add a shot of Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style 7 $22.00
Knob Creek Flight Knob Creek, Knob Creek Rye, Knob Creek Single Barrel | Add a shot of Paddlefish Knob Creek 7 $23.00
Uncle Nearest Flight Uncle Nearest 1884, Uncle Nearest 1856, Uncle Nearest Rye $22.00
Herradura Flight Herradura Silver, Herradura Reposado, Herradura Añejo | Add a shot of Herradura Ultra Cristalino Añejo 7 $22.00
Whiskey Flight from Around the World Harleston Scotch Whiskey, Mars Iwai Japanese Whiskey, Pop’s Canadian Whiskey | Add a shot of Paddlefish Knob Creek 7 $22.00